Training Camp Preview
Gonna be a long one but I want to get all things training camp out of the way before it starts Friday. Just jumping around position to position, and who should and will be playing by September 5th.
WR3: Randle, Hixon, Barden, Jernigan
Nicks and Cruz obvious number 1 and 2. What we need to look at here is the 3rd wide out. You have to believe that in 3 WR sets, Cruz will play the slot. This leaves 2nd rd pick Randle fighting it out with Barden and Hixon for the outside in my mind. Hixon is coming off his 2nd ACL tear in two years. Barden is injury prone and a huge disappointment. Jernigan is too small and is made for the slot with his speed.
Randle comes out on top and the 3rd WR for the Giants this year.
RB2: Ware, Wilson, Scott
Bradshaw is the starter. Question here is who comes in to replace Jacobs? Ware has the most size and experience. Wilson has the pure explosiveness and game breaking ability, pass blocking and fumbles are an issue. Da'Rel Scott is probably the fastest on the team and everyone remembers his 97 yard run last pre season, but after one fumble, he never touched the field again.
Ware looks like the favorite, Wilson will prove he has what it takes in camp/pre season
TE: Pascoe, Bennett, Robinson
Pascoe obviously has the most experience but it can be argued he is 2nd best in everything else. Bennett sat behind Witten in Dallas since he was drafted in 08, he can run block, pass block, and catch, basketball player in college, great redzone threat. Robinson "the JPP of tightends"is a project at this point. See what he can do in camp.
Bennett comes in and starts immediately for the Giants. I expect big things from him.
OL: Beatty LT (retina, then back in Spring drills.) Boothe LG, Diehl RT (broken hand) Snee RG (elbow) Baas C (head/neck)
From what I've read, they are all healthy, this should be starting O Line
FB: Hynoski
Has built himself into a baby bull. Great blocker, receiver out of the backfield
DT3: Rocky Benard, Shaun Rogers (elbow) Marvin Austin (torn pectoral)
Canty and Joseph are the starters so who will be number 3? Rocky Benard is the pre camp favorite with the most experience as a Giant. Shaun Rogers has size but has been a joke since we got him, claiming he has an elbow injury that no one wants to talk about. Marvin Austin hasn't played a meaningful game since December 2009, his junior year in college. He tore is pectoral muscle in the 3rd pre season game last year. He also brings speed to the DT position, and should be used by Fewell in many ways.
If the former 2nd rd pick Marvin Austin stays is healthy, I see him as the No.3 and making an impact
LB: The Linebacker story
It gets interesting here, as it stands now it looks like this, Kiwi (strong side) Blackburn (middle) Boley (weak side). This can all change with the play of Chase Blackburn. He can easily be replaced by Boley, opening up the weak side to Keith Rivers, the former No. 1 draft choice of the Bengals in 2008. Jaquian Williams is the nickle line backer with speed and coverage ability but I think there is too much competition for a starting role. Herzlich has an outside chance of actually starting this year if he can outplay Chase and Rivers in camp/preseason, I think he may need another year though. Greg Jones started 11 games at MLB last year, but once Chase came back, the Giants never looked back.
Kiwi. Boley. Rivers. I can't see Blackburn being an everyday starter. Rivers has too much raw ability
DE: Tuck, JPP, OSI
Let's be serious, best DE group in the league, they will be rotating around all season
CB2: Terrell Thomas (knee) Prince (foot)
Webster showed last year that he can be the shut down corner when we need him. So now it turns to the opposite corner. Terrell Thomas is coming off his 2nd torn ACL. He was thought to be a Pro Bowl candidate before the seasons started. Prince Amukamara broke his foot last year in his 2nd NFL practice and needed another procedure this off season, much less experience than TT.
The durability of TT's knee scares me. I can see Prince winning it in camp/preseason
The "Bison Role"(3rd Safety) Tyler Sash, Steve Brown, Will Hill, Deon Grant?
Kenny Phillips and Antrel Rolle are the starting two safeties for this team, but who takes on the 3rd safety, and/or "Bison Role". Tyler Sash has the experience in the Giants system over both Brown and Hill and is a great special teamer. Brown, like Hill, has been getting nothing but praise since he has come to the Giants this off season. Will Hill has zero NFL experience, a former No. 1 Recruit out of Jersey has all the athletic talent in the world. Fewell can use him in different ways, hope he has a great camp. I hope that Deon Grant doesn't come back, he played the Bison Role perfectly but he's old, and I think it is time to move on.
I think Sash gets the nod here with the experience, and Hill takes the 4th safety spot.
KR: David Wilson, Da'Rel Scott, Domenik Hixon
Wilson returned kicks at VaTech. Da'Rel Scott got some time there last year. Hixon when healthy has been returning both punts and kicks.
I love the Wilson/Scott combo. Pure speed. Save Hixon for WR work, no need to risk injury.
PR: Jayron Hosley, Jernigan, Hixon
Hosley returned punts at VaTech. Jernigan got some time there last season but most reps went to Aaron Ross. Again, when healthy Hixon was the teams return man.
Give Hosley a shot. Jernigan did not prove anything with last years opportunity, no Hixon risk